MAKING CENTS: Your financial questions answered


Don’t be left in the dark when if comes to your money
Question
Liam. I’ve been told that if I defer my state contributory pension until I’m 70 that I’ll end up with more money. Is that true and is it something I should consider?
Answer
I’m not sure you’ll end up getting more money as that will depend on how long you’ll live for but if you defer it until you’re 70, the amount you’ll receive each year will be more.
But let’s take a closer look at the numbers and compare two people who decide to take their benefits at different ages.
If John decides to retire at age 66 and let’s assume he’s in receipt of the maximum state pension, the amount he’ll get from the state is €299.30 per week (becoming €309.30 in 2027) or €15,563.60 per year.
And if Michael who also qualifies for the maximum state pension decides not to take his benefits until he’s 70, then he’ll receive €363.90 per week or €18,922.80 per year.
So, the difference between both is that Michael will get €3,359.20 more than John at age 70 for the rest of their lives.
However, because John has taken his pension 4 years earlier than Michael, he has received €62,254.40 (€15,563.60 x 4) before Michael begins to get his pension.
Which means it will take Michael 18.5 years before he gets to breakeven with John i.e. €62,254.40/€3,359.20 = 18.5
So, if both live to 88 and a half, they’ll have received the same amount. And if they both live past that age, Michael begins to receive more in total than John.
But he has to live past age 88.5 for that to happen.
And the life expectancy for a man in Ireland at the moment is 82. And the chances of a man living until 88.5 I believe is somewhere between 25% and 30%.
Question
Liam, I’m 24 and I’ve just being made permanent in my job. I earn €39,000 per year. I’ve been sharing my father’s car with him up until now but now I think I’d like to buy my own – I think he would too. My friends all have new cars and when I looked into buying a new car and what they’d cost I got a fright. If you had any advice I’d really appreciate it.
Answer
There is a great rule of thumb formula which can help you with this and it’s known as the 20-4-10 rule.
It puts parameters around the three car buying factors that affect your monthly budget, and its primary goal is to keep you from overextending yourself, and here’s how it works.
Have a deposit of at least 20% of the purchase price
Finance the car for no more than 4 years
And keep the monthly cost under 10% of your gross income
How you can apply the 20-4-10 Rule to You.
First, multiply your annual income by 10% and divide by 12 this is the amount you can apply each month towards the cost of owning a car.
€39,000 x 10% / 12 = €325.
Divide this amount by 0.024 and this will give you the amount you should borrow (0.024 is the cost per thousand if borrowing over a 4-year term using a rate of 8.10%)
€325/0.024 = €13,542.
So, this is the amount you should spend on your first car.
And perhaps it won’t get you the flashy car some of your friends are driving but I’d say keep it to that maximum and here’s why.
Let’s assume your friend and for this example let’s call him Eric, bought a newer car than you did and his cost him €27,000.
His monthly repayments are €650 per month and he financed his loan like you did over 4 years.
Eric was paying so much for his car that he couldn’t save much if anything each month.
You could have stretched yourself to the same €650 payment but instead you stuck to having a car payment of €325 and you set up a new savings account and saved €325 into it each month.
So, it’s the same €650 both of you were ‘spending’ except it was spread out a little differently.
Let’s fast forward 4 years.
Eric will have made interest and capital repayments totalling €31,200 on a car that in 4 years’ time will probably be worth €11,000 (it’s likely to have gone down in value by as much as 60%) and his savings balance will be €0.
You will have made interest and capital repayments amounting to €15,600 on a car that will probably be worth €5,500 but you’ll have c. €17,230 in a savings account (assumes an annual return of 5%)
I’ll leave you with this and I hope it stays with you as you start off on your work and financial journey.
Borrowing money is good when the something you buy goes up in value like a property or stocks.
Things like cars, or clothes or computers or phones almost always lose their value and there are times when you have to borrow money to buy things like the things I’ve just mentioned, of course there is, but it’s setting a limit on how much you spend which is the key.
With this new car of yours whilst it might be tempting to follow Eric’s example and spend twice as much as you should but you’ll end up paying twice as much in monthly repayments as well for something that might be parked and stationary 23 hours of the day.
In America if a cowboy is described as having a big hat but no cattle, it means they might drive a big car and have a big hat, but he’s no rancher, he doesn’t even have a ranch. They look wealthy but underneath it all everything they have is paid for by credit and they don’t really own anything. I’d say have a reasonable size hat and a really big ranch.
Question
Liam, I have a mortgage of €220,000 outstanding with 24 years remaining and the current rate is variable at 4.15%. I can afford to overpay €325 each month. I was wondering if it was better to overpay each month or make a lump sum payment each year? Which is better?
Answer
The annual overpayment is better and let me tell you why and by how much.
If you overpay each month at the €325 amount and your rate remains the same, you will clear your mortgage 93 months earlier and save yourself €45,371 in interest payments.
If you make an annual payment of €4,200 (€325 x 12) you will clear your mortgage 91 months earlier and save yourself €43,545 in interest payments.
You can see the annual overpayment creates a bigger impact but only by a small amount, so either or is fine.
The annual amount creates the better output for you because the balance outstanding on your mortgage is immediately lower when you make that one lump sum lodgement each year as opposed to it becoming lower by a smaller amount each month.
Question
Liam, I was recently made redundant and when it came to my redundancy payment I chose to waive my right to a future tax free lump sum so I could receive a higher termination payment. I did so believing that I could still take 25% from my pension fund if I moved it to a PRSA. I’ve been told now that this has changed or is about to change and I’m worried now I could miss out on this 25% tax free payment. Should I be worried?
Answer
Yes, you’re right to be worried.
Revenue has changed the legislation that impacts the taxation of redundancy payments and this interacts with pensions and in particular pension lump sums.
Previously only pension lump sums from occupational pension schemes (Execs/Master Trusts) were factored into these calculations and employees being made redundant had to make a decision as to whether or not to waive their right to a pension lump sum from their occupational pension scheme to receive better tax treatment on their termination payment.
This new change which was just announced in last month’s budget now broadens the definition of the pension lump sum (relevant capital sum) you take into account in the redundancy calculation to include a “relevant pension arrangement within the meaning of section 790AA” which includes a PRSA.
That is a significant change because PRSA’s historically had a different treatment in this context i.e. they simply fell outside of the approved scheme definition.
What all this means is that if you want to take your 25% tax free from your PRSA, you need to take it before year end otherwise you’ll be unable to.
Liam Croke is MD of Harmonics Financial Ltd, based in Plassey