Peacekeeper ‘angry’ at commanding officer after convoy separated, inquest told

Corporal Josh Phelan, Corporal Nathan Bryan and Trooper Shane Kearney leaving a building, carrying bagsplaceholder image
Corporal Josh Phelan, Corporal Nathan Bryan and Trooper Shane Kearney leaving a building, carrying bags

Corporal Josh Phelan was giving evidence on Thursday at the inquest into the death of Private Sean Rooney in Lebanon in 2022.

A commanding officer did not give a full mission briefing before a convoy carrying peacekeepers in Lebanon was ultimately subjected to a fatal attack, his second in command has told an inquest.

Corporal Josh Phelan recalled he was “angry” and “frustrated” with his commanding officer, Captain David Kelly, after the two vehicles became separated.

At Dublin District Coroner’s Court on Thursday, Cpl Phelan outlined how the rear vehicle was expected to follow Cpt Kelly’s but had missed a turn.

After his car was attacked, he said he had made phone calls looking for help to Cpt Kelly.

Cpl Phelan was in the passenger seat beside Private Sean Rooney, from Newtowncunningham in Co Donegal, who was driving the rear vehicle of the convoy when he was shot and killed on December 14, 2022.

They were accompanied in the armoured Toyota Land Cruiser by fellow Irish peacekeepers Trooper Nathan Bryan and Trooper Shane Kearney – who were also injured in the incident.

placeholder image

The inquest heard the vehicle they were in became surrounded by a hostile crowd of up to 60 people in a village, and they were later fired upon while attempting to escape.

They had been serving in the Unifil mission in Lebanon and were tasked with transporting Tpr Kearney and another peacekeeper in the lead vehicle to Beirut Airport as they had been granted bereavement leave.

Cpl Phelan told the inquest into Pte Rooney’s death on Thursday that he was second in command to Cpt Kelly for the two-vehicle transport mission and the senior man in the second Land Cruiser.

Under questioning from barrister Sean Guerin, for Pte Rooney’s family, Cpl Phelan said he would ordinarily expect to be given a detailed briefing from the patrol leader in the company office prior to departure.

He said this would include being given physical maps, a detailed explanation of the route, and also an exchange with the patrol leader to ensure he understood the route.

Cpl Phelan told the inquest, which heard from other witnesses that the briefings could take 45 minutes, that did not happen on the night in question.

placeholder image

He said instead there was a fragmentary order session, or FRAGO, at the vehicles before departure.

The inquest heard this potentially lasted less than 10 minutes and is normally used to give a brief update on any changes to orders or routes to those who had already been thoroughly briefed.

Cpl Phelan accepted there had been some pressure of time felt by members of the patrol prior to departure.

The inquest heard this was because there was a difficulty with the equipment of one of the vehicles, requiring a late change and delay to departure before the journey to Beirut Airport.

Under questioning from Mr Guerin, the corporal said he did not remember any threat assessment or orders relating to what to do if there was a loss of communications or separation of the vehicles.

The two-vehicle convoy stopped on the way to remove UN flags from the exterior of the vehicles at a UN post near the Litani River before continuing the journey.

placeholder image

The inquest has heard the first vehicle departed but it took several minutes for the second Land Cruiser to follow due to an apparent issue with a key fob.

Under questioning, Cpl Phelan agreed the planned route involved a turn to be made a relatively short distance from this UN outpost, but that had not been communicated to the rear vehicle during the stop.

He said they had continued straight on.

Coroner Dr Myra Cullinane asked the corporal about the extent of his knowledge of the route and if he had been briefed on specifics.

Cpl Phelan said they had not been specifically briefed, and added: “We were told essentially Captain Kelly had gone through the route I don’t know how many times.”

He told the inquest they were told Cpt Kelly was “extremely familiar” with the route and the FRAGO had involved codenames for roads, adding he did not have any memory of being told of a particular turn.

He agreed the plan was for the second vehicle to follow the Land Cruiser occupied by Cpt Kelly.

Cpl Phelan told Mr Guerin that, following the separation, Pte Rooney drove the vehicle reasonably fast in an effort to catch up to Cpt Kelly, and he did not remember slowing down at any junctions to check if the other vehicle had turned.

He said it was not his understanding that they were supposed to have turned off and joined a highway.

The inquest said there were instead travelling a different road along the coast.

The inquest heard that after a few minutes, Cpl Phelan realised they should have seen the other vehicle by that stage.

The jury was shown logs which outlined how Cpt Kelly had phone Cpl Phelan following the separation.

Cpl Phelan said: “We established we had gone wrong. I remember being angry with Cpt Kelly on the phone.”

placeholder image

Asked if he recalled what he said to the commanding officer, he replied: “No, I just remember being frustrated.”

He said the plan was to turn around and that Cpt Kelly would be waiting at the junction with his hazard lights on.

In going through the calls, Cpl Phelan told Mr Guerin he thought Cpt Kelly “made contact faster”.

The jury was also shown screenshots the peacekeeper took of their location on Google Maps that he had shared with his commanding officer between what were described as “calls for help” to the other car.

Cpl Phelan said he believed he told Cpt Kelly not to come but had told him to get a “quick reaction team” from the Irish base, Camp Shamrock, or the Lebanese Armed Forces as they were now outside the Unifil area of operations.

He said at one point, Pte Rooney’s door was prised open during the sustained attack but the bolt remained locked.

He also remembered hearing a “massive explosion” when the rear window of the vehicle was smashed by the hostile crowd.

The inquest is expected to continue into the middle of December.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice