Stade, Mr Darcy and 100 not out for Duncan

Colm Kinsella has plenty to talk about in his latest column on Munster rugby
IF it’s January it must be the European Cup and Munster fighting for their lives to make the knock-out stages.

IF it’s January it must be the European Cup and Munster fighting for their lives to make the knock-out stages.

We have been down this road so many times in the past.

However, January 2016 is somewhat unusual in that Munster will face three Champions Cup pool fixtures this month rather than the normal two.

Of course, the home leg with Stade Francais on Saturday week and the away tie with Treviso on Sunday, January 24 will be ‘dead rubbers’ should Munster fail to see off French champions Stade in this weekend’s re-arranged Round 2 clash at the Stade Jean Bouin.

The mindset of French clubs in European competition is a subject which has long since fascinated rugby supporters in Ireland and the UK.

Stade Francais, for instance have won 38 and lost four of their home European fixtutes to date. Away from home, the Top14 side has lost 23 times in European competition.

One member of the Munster squad who is very well placed to explain why French clubs appear far more determined to win home games than those ‘on the road’ is the province’s Wallaby second-row Mark Chisholm.

Chisholm spent a number of seasons as captain of Top 14 side Bayonne.

Explaining the apparent ‘home and away’ mentality of French clubs, Chrisholm explained: “I tried to knock it on the head for the four years I was over there, I tried to understand how you could be that way. By the end of it I started to realise that the Top 14 is such a tough competition where you see teams like Bayonne beating teams like Toulon at home.

”You’d say on paper it’s not possible but the amount of emphasis they put on winning their home games to keep out of the relegation zone is massive. You lose one home game and virtually you’re under pressure whether it be from round one or round 20, so the amount of pressure on winning your home games in the Top 14 just to stay in the Top 14 is immense.

”Our team (Bayonne) when we sit down to play at home and then play away often the coaches would pick and choose which games you wanted to target.

”Generally, down the bottom of the table if we were playing Grenoble or Brive away we’d sort of target that as a possible game to get a bonus losing point or the away win. Whereas if you come against a Clermont who are going to European Cup finals should you put out your full team and risk injury. Obviously the player pool in these bottom teams isn’t as great as the pool in the top teams. There’s all strategies and that behind it.

”Myself I don’t see any issue of not going out to win. I do not step on that field wanting to lose or thinking I’m going to lose. That’s my mentality but there’s other blokes who think it’s impossible to win and who won’t put in 100%.”

Asked if he had managed to change the mindset of many of his former team mates, Chisholm replied: “It was tough it was small steps but you have your chances and there is also all other little factors too.

”You don’t like to talk about referees but it was always that 50/50 decision that you know if we got that we could have won or been on the front foot.”


MUCH of the focus for rugby fans on Saturday may have been on Munster’s crucial Guinness Pro12 game away to Ulster, but for many of the grassroots supporters, the resumption of the AIL was their priority.

It seems incredible on many levels that the high profile clash of Ulster and Munster should take place on the same afternoon as a full round of club fixtures but then again should we really be surprised by such a clash given the way the club game has been allowed go.

Those who left the comfort of their armchairs to watch live rugby locally on Saturday could have done worse than have gone to Dooradoyle where Garryowen hosted Clontarf.

Among the familiar faces in ‘Tarf’s line-up was Matt D’Arcy, the talented centre who recently spent some time with Munster.

D’Arcy joined Munster on a short-term basis at the start of the 2015/16 season. Although he did not make a competitive appearance for the province,

D’Arcy featured in all three of Munster’s pre-season games and started for Munster A in the four rounds of this year’s British and Irish Cup, scoring a try against Ospreys Premiership Select.

D’Arcy was snapped up by Munster on the back of an impressive season for the Ireland Club XV captain which saw him become the Ulster Bank Division 1A Player of the Year as well as being the league’s top try scorer.

It was good to see a player who excelled in the club game get a chance to impress in the professional ranks. Hopefully, the trend will be continued with some more players – and closer to home as well.


MUNSTER’S timely Guinness Pro12 victory over Ulster on Saturday saw scrum-half Duncan Williams earn a milestone 100 caps for the province.

Williams joins teammates Tomás O’Leary, Denis Hurley, Donnacha Ryan, Billy Holland, Keith Earls, Tommy O’Donnell, Ian Keatley and BJ Botha in becoming the ninth current member of the squad to reach the 100 cap milestone.

Williams has showed admirable resilience during his time at Munster where he has been the second chance scrum-half since making his debut for the province in December 2009.

Williams won 47 of his 100 caps to date in the starting line-up, while 53 more came when he was introduced as a replacement.

Not all fans appear to appreciate his qualities as a player, but Munster showed big faith in him when offering him a two-year contract extension last February.

More News

Buy the e-paper of the Donegal Democrat, Donegal People's Press, Donegal Post and Inish Times here for instant access to Donegal's premier news titles.

Keep up with the latest news from Donegal with our daily newsletter featuring the most important stories of the day delivered to your inbox every evening at 5pm.