Making Cents! Pension losses require calm decisions


What do you do if your fund loses 15% of its value or what do you do, if it increases by 25%?
Over the past couple of months I’ve received call after call and email after email from people wanting to know what they should be doing with their pension and investment funds. And they reached out for advice because they can see the value of their fund yo-yo back and forth because of all the uncertainty around markets.
One week their fund is down 2% and the next week it's up 3% and it’s all a bit of a head wreck. And it’s fine when things are going up but when they’re going down some might need the help of a cardiologist.
Anyway the questions people are asking are good and really valid. I mean what do you do if your fund loses 15% of its value or what do you do, if it increases by 25%.
That’s an actual question I’m asking you and I want you to think about it for a second.
Do you do nothing ?
Or do you move some or all of your fund into higher or lower risk funds?
And if I said to you, that you should add 10% to one of them and sell 10% with the other, which scenario do you think I’d be referring to?
Before I answer the question, I want to tell you about a mini-survey I conducted for myself over the past two weeks where I asked this very question to about 30 people to see what they thought the answer was and what they would do.
And here's the thing, 28 of them or 93%, answered it I believe incorrectly.
My advice would be to add 10% to the fund that’s down 15% and take out 10% of the fund that’s up 25%.
There’s an old investment saying that says you should buy in the gloom and sell in the boom, but people’s instincts are the opposite where they get influenced by a wall of negativity about markets and if they are personally down 15% they think they should cut their losses move their fund into cash to stop the bleeding so to speak, but that’s exactly what they shouldn’t do. They are only crystalising a loss which is a paper one and making good on that loss which means they cannot regain it when the market recovers. And it will recover because markets are cyclical i.e. good times follow bad times and vice-versa.
There’s an old investment saying that says you should buy in the gloom and sell in the boom
And in fairness it’s just a natural instinct born out of fear that the 15% loss could become much higher and their fund will fall even further and there’s no doubt it is a risk and something like that could happen. You just don’t know with any degree of certainty whether it will or not, especially when you have a US President who can influence markets not based on cold hard factual data, but rather on what his gut is telling him.
Anyway, the reason you should be adding 10% more to your fund that has gone down in value is because (a) you are buying more shares/units within your fund at a low price and (b) as a result you are reducing your overall average cost per unit bought within the fund which means your fund doesn’t need to rise as much to make a profit compared to if you had done nothing.
And because you’re adding more money when the market is lower, your fund doesn't have to increase all the way back to its original price for you to break even. Within the financial services industry this is commonly known as buying the dip or averaging down.
The caveat with this strategy is your years to retirement.
If you have less than five years to retirement then perhaps you should be locking in some of what you have accumulated over the past 20 or 30 or 40 years, and if you’re in a fund that goes down in value by 15% and you’re very close to retirement i.e. less than two years then you’re probably in the wrong fund anyway because nobody’s fund should be impacted by that number when retirement is so close.
Losing 3% or 5% or 10% or even more can obviously be damaging for anyone, but it can be more problematic for people who are near retirement and my advice to them is to move their fund into cash and take away the uncertainty especially if they’re say less than 18 months to activating your fund.
Losing 3% or 5% or 10% or even more can obviously be damaging for anyone, but it can be more problematic for people who are near retirement
So adding 10% more to the value of a falling fund is mostly done by people who have 10 to 15 years before they retire because they have time on their side and expect the market will recover over time.
Let me give you an example of what you should do if your fund dropped in value by 15%.
And let’s say your fund is valued at €20,000 and it's down 15% and now it stands at €17,000. You should be adding (if you can that is) €2,000 more to the value of your fund. So, you now have €19,000 in your fund.
And don’t forget that if you do add €2,000 and you are paying tax at the higher rate of 40%, then the €2,000 is really only costing you €1,200 after tax relief.
And of course the bigger the size of your fund the bigger that 10% will cost you but adding more even if it’s not as much as 10% is something you should consider and again that’s assuming you have additional funds and you are 10 years+ to retirement.
It can obviously be much easier increasing your monthly contribution by 10% rather than putting in an additional 10% of the fund size.
If you were contributing say €1,200 per month and markets were down 15%, then that €1,200 is worth €1,020. So, if you increased your monthly contribution to €1,320 you’d be buying units in your pension fund at a lower average price than buying shares at the older higher price when you were saving €1,200 per month. That extra 10% means you end up buying more units in your fund.
Now if you fund was up 25% the advice might be to sell 10% of your fund and move it to a less risky fund than it's already in and that’s because you are banking this profit as well as reducing your risk and re-balancing your fund because the increase in your fund could have moved your initial asset allocation to a higher % than you want it to be at.
Let me explain that.
You might have started out with 55% of your contributions being invested equities with 45% invested in bonds. But if the growth is coming largely from your equity holding the split now might become 65% in equities and 35% and that might happen without you even knowing it and that split might not now be aligned to your risk profile.
By selling some of those growing equities and replacing them with less risky investments, you’ll minimize the impact of a stock market downturn.
And just a quick note about moving the gain, ideally you want to put it into a fund that will still see growth if markets improve and if they don’t you’ll lose less than the fund it came from. You don’t really want to put it into cash too quickly either because you’ll miss out on the bounce when markets rebound and if it’s in cash too long the return will probably be much lower than inflation which means in real terms the growth is going down in value.
Ideally you want to put it into a fund that will still see growth if markets improve and if they don’t you’ll lose less than the fund it came from
Cash might be the route to choose if (a) you’re going to access the fund in the next year or two and (b) the cash amount is the same or is as much of the 25% tax free amount you are allowed to take from your fund. You may want to ring fence this amount because you have a specific purpose for it and you’re okay that it’s not growing much if any in value, you’re happy with the amount you already have.
So, let’s say you have a fund which is valued at €200,000 and it’s a fund that has a risk rating of say 4. And this fund has increased in value by 25% from what you’ve put into it. In this instance you could take €50,000 out of the fund and move it into a fund that carries a lower risk rating of say a 3 or even a 2.
Now you have split one fund into two and the before and after could look something like this:
Before:
Risk Rating 4 - Fund Value: €200,000
Risk Rating 3 – Fund Value: €0
After:
Risk Rating 4 – Fund Value: €150,000
Risk Rating 3 – Fund Value: €50,000
I came across an article recently which gave some guidelines about what you should be doing to your pension and investment funds based on positive and negative returns. And what the author suggested were a set of rules of thumbs and I personally wouldn’t be making decisions or creating a plan based on a set of rules of thumbs because what they don’t know are the factors that are unique to an individual’s personal situation.
And obviously no two people are the same and what one rule says might be spot on for me, but it may not be for you so they shouldn’t be exclusively relied upon for making important financial decisions but I think they are useful, nonetheless.
And the action people should take that was suggested in the article I read was as follows:
Down 5% Do nothing
Down 15% Add 10% more
Down 25% Add 25% more
Up 5% Hold
Up 15% Sell 10%
Up 25% Sell 10%
Up 35% Sell 20%
Up 45% Sell 30%
Up 60% Sell 40%
Up 100% Exit fully
Everyone should be looking at their pension funds regardless of their age and putting a plan in place that allows them to benefit when the market is making gains but also protects them from the dangers of stock market volatility which will help make their losses less dramatic. And no doubt, it’s a bit of a balancing act to achieve that but it can be done.
And as with all of my articles, the advice I give is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. I would recommend that before you make any decision about what you should or shouldn’t do with your money that you first consult with your financial adviser and listen to what they have to say.
Liam Croke is MD of Harmonics Financial Ltd, based in Plassey. He can be contacted at [email protected]