Don’t put all your eggs in one basket warns Limerick financial adviser

placeholder image

Making Cents with Liam Croke - Limerick Live's must-read guide to saving money

I met an individual recently who wanted me to review the various pensions he had in place and what they all meant to him if he decided to retire at 60 or 62 or 65. He was 50 by the way.

And we ran the numbers and they looked good. They showed that at 62, based on the amount he was going to spend each month, he’d have enough built up in his pension pots that if he chose to, he’d never have to work again and that was great for him to hear.

The caveat though was that he’d have to stick to the current plan with his personal contributions and that of his current employer and he’d have to be mindful of the annual return he’d need on his funds which had to be a minimum of 3.4% per year.

If all of these things continued and were met, he was out the gate at 62 if he wanted to.

So, that was his pension out of the way and along with sharing all of his pension numbers he sent me a statement of his shareholdings with one of the companies he used to work for, and they were a very well-known biotechnology company that manufactured medical devices. He had worked for them in a senior role for about 15 years and over that time he had built up a significant amount of shares by way of awards, long-term incentives, purchases he made himself etc.

And this is very typical for someone in a role like him.

And the amount he had in place was significant, which is why he wanted me to have a look at them.

It was €273,513.

But hold on a second, I was reading the statement wrong. That was the value on January 1, 2026.

The value of the shares as of March 31, 2026 was €180,695.

So, over three months he had lost €92,818, which was a drop in value of 34%.

I put it to him that he had lost that amount in the space of just three months, and he said, yeah he knew alright and there was nothing he could do about it, but he must get around to it.

Which was a shocking statement because (a) he lost €92,818 and he couldn’t find the time to do something about it? (b) it wasn’t that he could afford to lose this amount, he absolutely couldn’t and (c) he had no clue about where he should invest these monies if he cut his losses and sold them.

And just a quick point on cutting his losses, that’s not quite correct. The price he had bought them at and the price he was awarded them at was lower than what the current price was even after such a drop, so he hadn’t lost money, he had just lost a bigger profit.

Anyway, things were about to take a turn for the worse because as we were speaking he logged in to his share portal and now the value was €143,678.

His loss since the start of the year was €129,835.

The value of his shares had reduced in value by 47%.

While he was telling me the new value, I was logging into another portal, and I was looking at the value of a fund that was very much diversified where it invested in 50 different companies in five different sectors and its performance since the start of the year was +13.45%.

This fund by the way changes the companies it invests in every month i.e. some are moved and some are brought in depending on what’s going on in the world and where it sees opportunities from growth with companies. And the ones that remain the percent invested in them might increase or decrease.

Anyway, when you put both of these returns alongside each other, it really shows the difference between both over exactly the same time period.

Starting Amount ReturnLoss/Gain Current Value

€273,513 -47% -€129,835 €143,678

€273,513 +13.45% +€36,787 €310,300

The monetary difference from what he lost and what he missed out on gaining was €66,622 and that was over just six months.

And unfortunately I had to tell him this and show him the figures, and I didn’t want him to feel any worse than what he was feeling already but this was hopefully going to be his call to action to do something about this.

And doing something could actually be doing nothing where he might decide to bide his time and hope or believe the share price would recover in time.

And nothing wrong with having that belief either but know that if you want to recover a 47% loss, you need an 88.68% gain to fully recover the 47% loss.

And was there any chance of that happening, who knows, crystal ball stuff.

The other option was to derisk his exposure to one stock and one sector and move to 50 stocks and five different sectors.

Which meant that if there was one company which had say a 1% holding in the fund and their share price fell in value by say 20% you’d lose a whole lot less.

Let me show you how.

Let’s say you invest €100,000 and the amount doesn’t matter, it’s just easy to use this figure, but the principle applies just the same as if the amount was €1,000.

So, if one company of the fifty accounts for say 1% of your investment then €1,000 of your €100,000 is invested in this company. And let’s say that company loses 20% of its share price, that means the €1,000 has dropped to €800.

Now, if you had everything invested only in that company, your €100,000 would now be valued at €80,000.

Again, let’s put them alongside each other:

Invested % in one company % Loss Monetary Loss

€100,000 100% 20% €20,000

€100,000 1% 20% €200

With that loss where you invest in 50 different companies, you have backup where you have lots of other companies who can cover that loss for you whereas investing in just one company, you have no backup and no cavalry.

And it may appear that I’m only focusing on the downside and I sort of am because of what happened to the individual I was telling you about.

So, it’s important to point out that if the shares went the other way, the €20,000 loss could have been a €20,000 gain and the €200 loss could have been a €200 gain.

And there is a big difference between both outcomes and investing in shares is like a double-edged sword i.e. you can make lots of money if successful but equally you could lose a lot or all of it, if you’re not.

So, it’s trying to avoid the dangerous half of the blade and that’s difficult.

And it’s a tightrope you have to walk.

Do you spread your risk and walk it knowing there’s a net below to catch you (investing in multiple companies in different sectors) or do you forgo the net and walk without any protection below because if you get across without falling you’re a hero and the reward is possibly much greater?

That’s a decision people have to make when they look at the potential downside and upside, and which are they willing to choose. And maybe it doesn’t have to be one or the other, maybe you can do both so that you can benefit bigger when markets/companies are performing well and lose less when they aren’t.

And that’s exactly what we did to the person I was telling you about.

Our plan of action and what we followed though in doing was to leave the €41,000 invested in that one company because who knows it might make a miraculous recovery and she’ll benefit from that happening, but in the event it didn’t she had €100,000 in the 50 different companies fund.

And I’m delighted to say that since the new account was opened four weeks ago it has grown in value by 3.40% so her fund now stands at €103,400 and over the same time period the company she left the €41,000 with is down -2.40%.

Which is slightly more tolerable on the amount she left invested in it, but the new fund has covered that loss so she’s still net positive even carrying that loss. Which really proves that point about why diversifying is so important.

I’ll leave you with this.

Up until the beginning of the millennia the majority of people believed you had to invest in one, possibly two high-growth companies if you wanted to make money.

But of course the opposite is also true, because if you picked the wrong companies you could lose everything as well.

I’m a big believer in being able to reduce that risk of wiping out your entire savings whilst still producing excellent returns if you invest in not just one or two stocks but in forty or perhaps even fifty.

And you shouldn’t limit your investments to just investing in companies either, you should spread your risk further by investing in other asset classes like government and corporate bonds, property, cash, commodities and so on.

With this type of approach you don’t have to get lucky to produce great returns and that’s because the value of shares in different companies don’t all move in the same direction i.e. in recessionary times some companies will perform much better than others, the same applies when inflation is high or low or when there are geopolitical issues to contend with which is why you should invest in companies involved in different sectors like technology, pharmaceutical, finance, consumer, energy, real estate, telecommunications etc.

Liam Croke is MD of Harmonics Financial Ltd, based in Plassey

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice