Limerick financial adviser: Overpay mortgage or invest extra money?


Making Cents with Liam Croke - Limerick Live's must-read guide to saving money
Question
I am looking for your advice please in relation to the following.
I currently have circa $200,000 in a dollar account and wondered if I should convert to euro and put it in an investment account or wait until the dollar hopefully strengthens.
Answer
Forecasting where the EUR/USD exchange rate will go is very difficult and rarely ever done with accuracy in the short-term. Recent days have demonstrated why this is the case. The Euro has weakened in response to the conflict in the Middle East over concerns that rising energy costs will be inflationary. Meanwhile, the dollar has become a safe haven due to American energy independence and has therefore strengthened. This has moved the EUR/USD exchange rate from above 1.18 down to 1.16 in a matter of days (we saw the exchange rate move in the opposite direction back in January due to the “Sell America” trade around the Greenland situation and the renewed threat of US tariffs).
This is against consensus expectations in 2026 for the USD to weaken against the EUR due to the ECB being expected to be closer to the end of their rate cutting cycle than the Federal Reserve, with the Fed expected to cut rates twice this year.
Lower interest rates in the US would theoretically lead to a weaker dollar. However, the current inflation and labour market outlook in the US make the expectation for rate cuts more uncertain.
It’s also unclear how much of this expectation is already priced into the exchange rate. In addition, the nomination of Kevin Warsh as the new Federal Reserve chair has also impacted the outlook on interest rates due to his history of hawkish views. Although appointed by Trump, he might not necessarily be a ‘Yes’ man, which would liken him to the current Fed chair Powell. Trump wants a weaker dollar but Warsh in the past has been outspoken of his support for a stronger dollar. And it must be noted policies take time to be implemented as well.
So, as you can see, projecting the EUR/USD exchange rate is difficult in that it requires accurate forecasting of macroeconomic conditions (interest rates, inflation, trade balances, public debt etc) for both the US and Europe, while unexpected geopolitical developments such as the ones in Greenland and the Middle East this year can also play a significant part.
Question
Liam, I’ve just taken on a new mortgage of €400,000 over 25 years. My repayments are €1,996 per month and are based on a variable rate of 3.47%. I have surplus monies of about €300 that I could apply as an overpayment on my mortgage or would I be better off investing the money instead? I have other money so it’s not essential that I build back up my savings. But I wanted to check in with you to see what the best outcome from a financial perspective is.
Answer
Okay the best way I think I can answer this question is by showing you that if I saved the €300 each month and you overpay your mortgage by €300, let’s see where both of us land in 25 years’ time.
Let’s start with you.
If you make that overpayment, you will reduce the term of your mortgage by four years and nine months and you’ll save €41,710 in interest payments. And that’s the first number we’ve got to remember.
As an aside If you did implement the monthly overpayment of €300, you are also reducing the effective interest rate your lender is charging you and rather than paying them on average 3.47% over the course of your mortgage, by implementing that overpayment your effective rate becomes 2.69%.
Okay, with the mortgage gone you can now save that full mortgage repayment of €1,996 for the next 57 months and if you did and got an annual return of 4%, you’d accumulate €125,069.91 of which €11,298 would have been interest.
The financial outcome by overpaying your mortgage after 25 years is that you would save €41,710 in interest payments and then you’d earn €11,298 after diverting the mortgage repayment and investing it.
So, your number is €53,008.
Now me.
I’m not going to use the €300 as an overpayment on my mortgage and instead I’m going to save it.
And I save €300 for 35 years and I get an annual return of 4%, I’m going to end up with €154,239 of which €64,239 was interest earned.
So, from a financial perspective I’m going to have a better outcome than you will, by a margin of €11,231 i.e. €64,239 - €53,008.
But that’s assuming I get that net annual return of 4% each year.
If I got a net return of say 2% per year, then the interest I’d earn would be €26,646 and you’d have that is nearly twice as big as mine.
So, the return is a big factor.
You’d need to get a net return that is greater than 3.47% each year for the investment route to be better than by applying the €300 as an overpayment on your mortgage, anything less than that and the overpayment on your mortgage creates the best outcome.
Which begs the question as to why would you take the risk with an investment when you are getting a guaranteed return if applying it against your mortgage because whatever rate your mortgage is being charged at, is the net return you are getting.
With an investment, in order to net down to 3.47% you’d need to be getting an annual return of about 6.67% because that’s the return that would net down to 3.47% after you account for tax and investment management fees. And is that possible? Yes, but you would have to invest in high risk accounts if you wanted that type of return.
And I’m not trying to convince you either way, I just wanted to present the facts and once you know what they are, you can decide which suits you best. Sometimes the decision to choose one strategy over another isn’t just all about the money, some people will choose a route that produces a lower return because the route from a non-financial perspective suits them better and again, that’s fine as well. I always tell people that you’re the average of one and the important thing and what’s best for you mightn’t be for everyone else.
Liam Croke is MD of Harmonics Financial Ltd, based in Plassey