‘Fair’ Budget but fundamental problems remain, says haulage operator


Paul Toner compared companies to being like a ‘mouse on the wheel running so hard to stay alive’, with a ‘squeeze on every week’.
Rising fuel prices have been “horrendous” for hauliers, one operator said as warned that issues affecting the industry are much broader.
Paul Toner, managing director of Toner Transport and Logistics in Rathcoole, Co Dublin, said Budget 2027 seemed “fair” but raised some concerns over costs borne by the haulage industry.
He told the Press Association: “They’re trying to help everyone. So they are listening, which is hugely important.”
Mr Toner welcomed extensions of a 32-cent-per-litre excise duty cut on diesel and the road transporters support scheme (RTSS), adding: “Only for that, I don’t think there would be a lot of trucks moving.”
However, he was concerned that hydrotreated vegetable oil (HVO)- a biofuel alternative to diesel used by 70% of their fleet – did not qualify for the diesel rebate scheme.
Mr Toner said: “In fairness, the RTSS scheme that the Government gave us was very helpful.
“It really came at the most vulnerable time, and we’re very grateful for that.”
He said Toner Transport and Logistics used 1.5 million litres of HVO and was “really trying to green our economy”, but ended up losing out on more than 100,000 euro it would have received under the rebate scheme if it had been using diesel, as well as similar savings in the price per litre.
Mr Toner contended that an Irish Road Haulage Association study showed it would be cost-neutral for HVO to be given a 24-cent rebate due to projected carbon emission reductions, which would lessen potential fines levelled on the state for missing climate targets.
“We were feeling great about what we were doing.
“But then in March of this year, just when things started to go pear-shaped altogether, we just had to go back to diesel, which kills me because diesel is so dirty.”
“Over the last three years, it has been just over seven million euro gross turnover – that’s employing 50 people – but the Government takes 32% of that if you add up all of our taxes together.
“So there’s nothing left for us, Toner Transport and Logistics, to survive or to grow or to buy new equipment, do all sorts that needs to be done.
“Any money you accumulate, you put it back in to the business.”
He added: “For three years on our accounts, we have broken even – zero, zero.”
“The Government takes 2.1 million of our seven-million gross turnover – why can’t we make 300-350,000 (euro) and the Government be happy with 1.7 million? They want it all. Tax, tax, tax.”
Mr Toner criticised the Government’s handling of the local economy, adding: “Taoiseach Micheál Martin is afraid of his life because of the previous Fianna Fáil government back in the crash, that he wants to have the Government with the healthiest bank balance.
“There’s no point of that if companies are closing or close to closing.”
Mr Toner compared companies to being like a “mouse on the wheel running so hard to stay alive”, with a “squeeze on every week”, around VAT, PAYE, PRSI and the employers’ contribution and auto-enrolment.
The Government did announce a hike in the employer PRSI threshold from 2027, which is designed to save 650-700 euro per employee over the course of the year.
Mr Toner said “this has to help”, but added he wanted to see the Government “ease the haulage industry’s plight of taxation”.
Mr Toner also said the Government should introduce exemptions for tolls on articulated trucks.
Reflecting on the scenes of disruption across the country over fuel concerns earlier in the year, Mr Toner said the IRHA had not wanted to protest.
“A huge cohort do want to protest – but protesting is not going to get us anywhere.”