Budget a test that Government has ‘failed’ – Doherty


Sinn Fein TD Pearse Doherty said it had been an opportunity to act on the housing crisis, fuel prices and help children with disabilities.
The Budget was a test which the Government has “failed”, the coalition leaders have been told.
Sinn Féin TD Pearse Doherty (Sinn Féin) condemned the Budget as an “insult to workers”.
Speaking in the Oireachtas, Mr Doherty said the real test of the measures will be at the end of the month when bills are paid and the Budget “fails completely”.
He said the Budget is about choices, and that the Government has left workers behind, adding that the “majority” of Irish workers “won’t get a sniff at” the 750 euro tax break.
“Time and time again, this Government leaves ordinary Irish people behind, those who keep Ireland moving, those who work hard and who are trying to build a life,” he said.
“The majority of Irish workers, over a million and a half of them, who you’ve left abandoned in this Budget will get less than 250 euro in a tax break.
“That is an insult, minister, and you have the cheek to stand here and say that this is a Budget for workers.”
Mr Doherty said families across Ireland “desperately needed” the Government to act on the spiralling cost of energy and fuel.
He told TDs that hundreds of thousands of households are “already struggling to keep the lights and heat on”, with more than 300,000 homes behind on their electricity bills.
He said a reduction of less than 50 euro for filling an oil tank “is an insult”, and “nowhere near the scale of the crisis”.
Turning to the housing crisis, Mr Doherty said it is getting worse, saying that 5,000 children in Ireland are homeless.
“The urgency in relation to this crisis is nowhere to be seen in this housing budget, because we are in a housing emergency, a crisis reshaping how an entire generation lives,” he said.
“That’s probably the biggest indictment of Government’s failure in terms of policy … years of rent, years of saving, years of watching house prices climb faster and faster and faster, and their deposits still not there.
“That demanded a massive response from Government … but what did we get from Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael? No increased funding for building homes … rents are soaring, mortgage burdens have grown, homelessness has risen.
He criticised a “miserable 150 euro increase in the renters’ tax credit”, saying they will be “gone before they even get it”, and Government’s “refusal to ban rent increases”.
“We have more than 5,000 children today homeless in this state, one of the most wealthiest countries in the world … no-one should have to grow up in a hotel room and call that home.
“But that’s the reality that Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil have created in this Ireland of 2026 and for many years.”
Summing up, Mr Doherty said the Government had “made the wrong choices” in the Budget and “failed”, adding “ordinary people deserve so much more”.
He said budgets are “all about priorities”.
“They’re about who gets protected, they are about who is asked to contribute, and what your Government treats as urgent, and who is told once again to wait,” he said.
Mr Doherty said workers are still facing high prices, renters still facing record rents, families continuing to have some of the highest energy costs in Europe, children with disabilities still waiting for assessments, patients still waiting for care and more than 5,000 children without a home.
“These are the realities against what your budget needs to be judged – not by a press conference, not by spin, not by a glossy booklet, not by a ministerial soundbite,” he said.
“Politics is ultimately about choices, and you can accept record rents, or you can bring them down, you can tolerate children growing up homeless, or you can build the homes that their family needs, you can allow energy companies to make bumper profits while families sit in cold homes, or you can intervene and stand up for people.”
He added those were the simple test in this year’s Budget.
“It was a test that you failed,” he said, adding that “wrong choices were made”, for which workers and families will live with the consequences.
“Ordinary people deserve so, so much better than what you have delivered here today.”