Brothers jailed over Limerick city attack

David Hurley

Reporter:

David Hurley

Judge Tom O'Donnell imposed prison sentences totalling two-and-a-half years imprisonment suspending the final six months.
TWO brothers who violently attacked a man who was sitting in a parked car outside his girlfriend’s home after returning from the cinema have received lengthy prison sentences.

TWO brothers who violently attacked a man who was sitting in a parked car outside his girlfriend’s home after returning from the cinema have received lengthy prison sentences.

Sentencing Robert O’Donnell, aged 20, and Christopher O’Donnell, aged 22, both of Clarina Avenue, Ballinacurra Weston, Judge Tom O’Donnell noted there is a high risk of both men reoffending.

During a sentencing hearing, Limerick Circuit Court was told the pair attacked Gerard Fogarty at Quinn Cottages, Rosbrien at around 11pm on February 22, 2104.

The incident happened after Robert O’Donnell approached Mr Fogarty’s car and asked for a cigarette.

Detective Garda Paul Crowley said words were exchanged and “suddenly and without provocation” the injured party was pulled from the car and set upon.

He sustained a “vicious beating” and suffered a broken nose after he was punched in the face during the attack.

“He was struck with a large rock into the ribs and blows were reigned on his head and body,” he added.

Both men identified themselves in CCTV footage which was recovered from the area.

The court was told both have a large number of previous convictions and come from a difficult family background.

Imposing sentence Judge O’Donnell described the incident as a “totally unprovoked gratuitous assault on a totally innocent party”.

Commenting on the contents of a probation report, he noted that bush drinking is a major issue of concern.

The judge said he accepted that the brothers had not intended assaulting Mr Fogarty and that it was a “spontaneous matter which escalated”.

While conscious of the defendant’s’ age and their “unstructured lifestyle” Judge O’Donnell said the matter was serious and that a custodial sentence “must be handed down”.

He imposed prison sentences totalling two-and-a-half years imprisonment suspending the final six months.